Brint, I have to admit up front that I have not seen all of the movies that made your list. In fact, I have only seen 40% of them. But of the movies that I have seen in 2006, V for Vendetta and Casino Royale would be much higher on my list than 7 & 8. This has a lot to do with my taste in movies, but I give a LOT of credence to whether I would watch the movie again or even purchase it. Well, I have seen V more than once and plan on at least watching Royale again if not purchasing it. Children of Men, probably not. I won't say that I would never watch it again, but I most likely won't seek it out. Unfortunately I haven't seen any of your top 4 YET (I plan to), and I most likely won't see Borat. Anyway, wanted to offer my thoughts taht 7 & 8 were underrated.

I did say in the original post that it was really hard to rate the movies as they are very different. Some drama, some action, and some comedy. So, putting them in any sort of order was tough. I agree that wanting to watch a movie again is a plus, but that doesn't necessarily make it a better movie then a great film that you never want to see again. And there are those films. United 93 for example is outstanding... but I don't want to watch it again.

You definitely have to check out the top four and Borat! They are great!